Why most redesigns lose traffic
The classic redesign failure mode: new design ships, URLs change, redirects are missing or wrong, structured data is dropped, page weight balloons because of new fonts and animations, and three months later organic traffic is down 40%. The redesign "looks better" but the business performs worse.
This happens because most agencies treat redesign as a visual project, not a technical one. We treat it as both. The visual work and the SEO/technical migration plan run in parallel from week one.
Our website redesign process
- Audit week. Analytics review (top pages, top sources, conversion paths), Search Console crawl (indexed URLs, queries, impressions), Lighthouse on top 10 pages, accessibility scan (WCAG 2.2 AA), structured data check, broken links scan.
- Migration map. Spreadsheet of every URL on the current site, classified: keep, change-and-redirect, retire-and-redirect, retire-and-410. Redirect plan signed off before any new design starts.
- Information architecture. New sitemap based on the audit — keeping the URLs that earn traffic, consolidating thin pages, splitting overloaded ones.
- Design and build. Standard custom design process, but with the migration plan as a hard constraint.
- Pre-launch QA. Staging crawl validated against the migration map. Every redirect tested. Structured data validated. CWV measured.
- Launch and monitor. Cutover, immediate Search Console resubmission, daily monitoring of indexed URL count and impressions for the first 4 weeks. Roll back any redirect that misbehaves.
What we keep, what we rebuild
An audit-led redesign rarely justifies starting from zero. We typically keep:
- URLs that earn traffic — same path, refreshed content
- Brand assets that work — logo, color palette if proven, name typography
- Content that ranks — sometimes lightly rewritten, sometimes preserved
- Conversion paths that perform — same form fields, CTA wording where data shows it works
And we rebuild:
- The design system, layout, typography, imagery
- Information architecture if the audit shows confusion
- Performance from the ground up (Core Web Vitals)
- Technical SEO foundations (sitemap, structured data, hreflang)
- Accessibility
- CMS schema
SEO during a redesign
The biggest SEO risks in a redesign: changing URLs without redirects, dropping structured data, losing internal links, removing pages that bring traffic. Our redirect map handles the first; rebuilding structured data into every template handles the second; treating internal linking as a deliberate task handles the third; the audit-driven sitemap handles the fourth.
For sites that need extra technical work after the redesign, see our website optimization service.
Where website redesign connects to other services
- Web design overview — parent service
- Custom web design — what the new site usually is
- Responsive web design — usually one of the things being added
- Website optimization — alternative when the visual is fine but performance/SEO is not
- E-commerce development — for store redesigns specifically
Frequently asked about website redesigns
How long does a website redesign take?
Typical: 8-14 weeks depending on size. The audit week is fixed. The build phase scales with page count and custom components.
Can you redesign just part of the site?
Yes. We do partial redesigns — homepage + top landing pages — for clients who do not need a full rebuild. The migration plan still applies to whatever URLs change.
Will my SEO drop during the transition?
Some short-term fluctuation is normal during the first 2-3 weeks while Google re-crawls and re-indexes. Done correctly, traffic recovers and usually grows within 4-8 weeks because the new site is faster, cleaner and more semantic. The redirect map is the insurance policy against permanent loss.
This is one of six tracks under our web design services. If your project covers more than one — for example, you need both a redesign and an e-commerce layer — we scope it as a single engagement under the parent service.
Talk about your website redesign project
Tell us about the project. We'll respond within 24-48 hours with a fixed-scope proposal: timeline, deliverables and budget.
Start a project →